Stephanie Jane recenzis Stolen Summers de Anne Goodwin
An emotional read
5 steloj
Although I already had some idea of Matty's story, having read Matilda Windsor Is Coming Home last year, I wasn't prepared for just how emotional this novel would make me. The sheer unfairness of Matty's enforced hospitalisation made me particularly angry, especially as by seeing the experience through her eyes, I soon realised that she really did have no idea of what was waiting for her. Matty's naivete in the first chapter is heartbreaking. I don't often cry while reading, but my advice for Stolen Summers is to have a handkerchief near to hand.
Anne Goodwin portrays Matty and her fellow Ghyllside residents with great sensitivity so, while I could appreciate the absurdities of their situation, I never felt the patients themselves to be absurd. Indeed, the shifting social policies and expectations that dictate their treatments and freedoms seem to be the cause of many of Matty's troubles. Some of …
Although I already had some idea of Matty's story, having read Matilda Windsor Is Coming Home last year, I wasn't prepared for just how emotional this novel would make me. The sheer unfairness of Matty's enforced hospitalisation made me particularly angry, especially as by seeing the experience through her eyes, I soon realised that she really did have no idea of what was waiting for her. Matty's naivete in the first chapter is heartbreaking. I don't often cry while reading, but my advice for Stolen Summers is to have a handkerchief near to hand.
Anne Goodwin portrays Matty and her fellow Ghyllside residents with great sensitivity so, while I could appreciate the absurdities of their situation, I never felt the patients themselves to be absurd. Indeed, the shifting social policies and expectations that dictate their treatments and freedoms seem to be the cause of many of Matty's troubles. Some of those historical 'treatments' are just awful. The powerful aspect of Stolen Summers for me though waas to witness how a perfectly healthy, vibrant young woman was turned into the totally institutionalised Matty by a system that she should never have been anywhere near in the first place. Stolen Summers is a beautifully written story which made me both angry and very sad.