Stephanie Jane recenzis The Promise de Michelle Vernal
Wonderfully uplifting
3 steloj
The Promise is a heart warming story of a young woman, Isabel, finding herself after a broken heart, and an elderly woman, Constance, rediscovering her spark after thinking a care home was The End. Both are wonderfully created characters, quirky but always genuine, and I enjoyed spending time with them. The narrative takes in themes of self identity, friendship, adoption and family with the fascinating contrast of seeing these ideas explored from both youthful and aged perspectives. I especially loved Constance. She is witty and often sharp, but at the same time is great fun. The supporting cast are also all completely believable and their interactions add a real depth to the story.
I was disappointed that The Promise is let down by poor proofreading and research, incidences of which would suddenly snap me out of Vernal's carefully crafted atmosphere. For example, the Isle of Wight is almost always just …
The Promise is a heart warming story of a young woman, Isabel, finding herself after a broken heart, and an elderly woman, Constance, rediscovering her spark after thinking a care home was The End. Both are wonderfully created characters, quirky but always genuine, and I enjoyed spending time with them. The narrative takes in themes of self identity, friendship, adoption and family with the fascinating contrast of seeing these ideas explored from both youthful and aged perspectives. I especially loved Constance. She is witty and often sharp, but at the same time is great fun. The supporting cast are also all completely believable and their interactions add a real depth to the story.
I was disappointed that The Promise is let down by poor proofreading and research, incidences of which would suddenly snap me out of Vernal's carefully crafted atmosphere. For example, the Isle of Wight is almost always just referred to as Wight which jarred with me and, at one point, Isabel's father 'pressed a crisp hundred-pound note into her hand'. Where on earth did he manage to find that in Southampton? Edinburgh maybe! There's frequent use of Antipodean slang as well which, as most of the characters are supposed to be British, felt very strange and was often inadvertently humorous - words such as 'skivvy' have very different meanings! However, other than these minor distractions, The Promise is a wonderfully uplifting read.