Stephanie Jane recenzis Blackmail, Sex and Lies de Kathryn McMaster
A fascinating affair
3 steloj
I don't remember having been aware of the Madeleine Smith / Pierre Emile d'Angelier poisoning case prior to reading Blackmail, Sex And Lies despite, like Kathryn McMaster, being a keen reader of true crime books as a teenager. It's a fascinating affair of young love set against strict Victorian rules and I couldn't help but wonder if there would have been such a murderous outcome if the situation arose in our less class-defined society these days - excepting that it is now far more difficult to buy sufficient arsenic of course!
I liked how McMaster combines fiction and nonfiction elements within her novel. The writing style is very much nonfiction rather than historical fiction. The inclusion of lots of Madeleine's genuine letters to Emile adds great authenticity and fictional scenes are cleverly woven around them so we can experience events as McMaster imagines them before reading Madeleine's own words written …
I don't remember having been aware of the Madeleine Smith / Pierre Emile d'Angelier poisoning case prior to reading Blackmail, Sex And Lies despite, like Kathryn McMaster, being a keen reader of true crime books as a teenager. It's a fascinating affair of young love set against strict Victorian rules and I couldn't help but wonder if there would have been such a murderous outcome if the situation arose in our less class-defined society these days - excepting that it is now far more difficult to buy sufficient arsenic of course!
I liked how McMaster combines fiction and nonfiction elements within her novel. The writing style is very much nonfiction rather than historical fiction. The inclusion of lots of Madeleine's genuine letters to Emile adds great authenticity and fictional scenes are cleverly woven around them so we can experience events as McMaster imagines them before reading Madeleine's own words written at the time. Dialogue is occasionally a tad clunky, but I felt I got a good idea of Madeleine and Emile's characters - she the naive socialite, he the obsessive and controlling older man. At times I wondered what on earth attracted Madeleine to such a bullying and (by modern standards) obviously disturbed potential partner, but considering the other men she was allowed to meet and the example of her dictatorial father helped to understand her motivations.
Blackmail, Sex And Lies details every aspect of Madeleine and Emile's relationship, but refrains from 'taking sides' until the very end. We as readers are given the facts and allowed to make our own minds up about guilt and innocence before McMaster weighs in with her thoughts on the legal outcome. It's an interesting device, quite different to most historical fiction I read so refreshing in that sense, although as a result I did sometimes feel more detached from the story than I would have liked.