Stephanie Jane recenzis The Paper Bark Tree Mystery de Ovidia Yu
Detailed historical fiction
3 steloj
The Paper Bark Tree Mystery is the third of Ovidia Yu's Crown Colony crime detection series set in the then British colony of Singapore during the period between the two world wars. I, of course, hadn't previously read the first two books and as a result I think I missed out on character development that had gone before. That said, I really liked Su Lin and appreciated the way in which readers see 1930s Singapore through her eyes. A polio survivor, she does struggle to walk or stand for longer periods of time and this disability means her talents are often overlooked by those around her. Su Lin is also overlooked by members of the colonial administration because of her native Singapore nationality. Yu explores Singapore's racial divides, making interesting points through Su Lin's observations. The island seems to be a melting pot of peoples from all across Asia, with …
The Paper Bark Tree Mystery is the third of Ovidia Yu's Crown Colony crime detection series set in the then British colony of Singapore during the period between the two world wars. I, of course, hadn't previously read the first two books and as a result I think I missed out on character development that had gone before. That said, I really liked Su Lin and appreciated the way in which readers see 1930s Singapore through her eyes. A polio survivor, she does struggle to walk or stand for longer periods of time and this disability means her talents are often overlooked by those around her. Su Lin is also overlooked by members of the colonial administration because of her native Singapore nationality. Yu explores Singapore's racial divides, making interesting points through Su Lin's observations. The island seems to be a melting pot of peoples from all across Asia, with the white Brits presuming to stand above everybody else.
The criminal mystery at the heart of this story unravels in quite a convoluted way with lots of potential suspects. Unfortunately it didn't always keep my attention which was a shame as this novel, in theory at least, should have strongly appealed to me. It's nicely detailed historical fiction which allowed me to learn about the time and place in which it is set. Occasional mentions of the potential for an imminent Second World War add a tense layer of foreboding - especially as my recent reading of How We Disappeared by Jing-Jing Lee meant I was all too painfully aware of what will soon happen. Perhaps I should give the first Crown Colony book a try and work my way back to this one in order to fully appreciate it. The central narrative does satisfactorily stand alone, but I think I would benefit from a deeper understanding of the characters surrounding Su Lin, and I would happily read more of Ovidia Yu's writing so this would be a good excuse!