Stephanie Jane recenzis Reservoir 13 de Jon McGregor
Wonderfully unexpected
5 steloj
I was concerned, on starting this novel, by the proportion of truly terrible reviews it has. There are many five-stars, but also a significant proportion of one-stars. Having enjoyed McGregor's earlier novel, If Nobody Speaks Of Remarkable Things, though, I wanted to read this one as well and fairly soon realised why Reservoir 13 causes such division amongst reviewers. The story starts with the disappearance of Rebecca, a teenage girl, so convention has it that this event should soon be followed by the appearance of a Dysfunctional Detective, possibly with a tenuous Personal Connection to the case, and culminate in an against-the-clock race to save another Innocent Victim. McGregor steers well clear of all these tropes! Instead he tells the stories of the village from which the girl disappeared in the thirteen years following her disappearance. It's a beautiful portrait of a community ripped open and then finding its heart …
I was concerned, on starting this novel, by the proportion of truly terrible reviews it has. There are many five-stars, but also a significant proportion of one-stars. Having enjoyed McGregor's earlier novel, If Nobody Speaks Of Remarkable Things, though, I wanted to read this one as well and fairly soon realised why Reservoir 13 causes such division amongst reviewers. The story starts with the disappearance of Rebecca, a teenage girl, so convention has it that this event should soon be followed by the appearance of a Dysfunctional Detective, possibly with a tenuous Personal Connection to the case, and culminate in an against-the-clock race to save another Innocent Victim. McGregor steers well clear of all these tropes! Instead he tells the stories of the village from which the girl disappeared in the thirteen years following her disappearance. It's a beautiful portrait of a community ripped open and then finding its heart again, but I think more suited to fans of Robert McFarlane than, say, Lauren Carr.
I loved McGregor's inclusion of the natural world rhythms alongside people's lives and traditions. Fox cubs learn to play as swallows arrive and then depart. Cricket matches are lost, harvest festival altars decorated, and the well must be dressed. It often seems as though Rebecca (or Becky or Bex) has been forgotten, but the effect of her tragedy is long-lasting. She is at the centre of the novel both for what happened and in time. She was thirteen at the beginning of this book and McGregor chronicles the next thirteen years, one per chapter, which I felt gave a good sense of balance to the story. The villagers are reminded by news crews descending on significant anniversaries or the rarely-seen presence of her mother. However, they also have their own lives to live and McGregor's observations of daily minutiae is superb. A wonderful and wonderfully unexpected novel!