Stephanie Jane recenzis Perils and Pearls de Hulda Bachman-Neeb
A multi-generational memoir
3 steloj
Perils And Pearls tells the story of a colonial Dutch family from their earliest incursions into Indonesia until their eventual return to the Netherlands at Indonesian independence. The book starts with a family history of the men, who were mostly military doctors, going back as far as the 1600s and 1700s when the Dutch nation exported many of its people under the auspices of the Dutch East Indies Company. The Dutch history in east Asia at this time and on through the Victorian era shares similarities with British empire building so I recognised a lot of the scenarios although I did at times struggle to remember who was who of Bachman-Neeb's ancestors because we jump from one to another and their careers often follow the same trajectories!
Once we meet Bachman-Neeb's immediate family in the 1930s, the pace slows so I could begin to get a better idea of individual …
Perils And Pearls tells the story of a colonial Dutch family from their earliest incursions into Indonesia until their eventual return to the Netherlands at Indonesian independence. The book starts with a family history of the men, who were mostly military doctors, going back as far as the 1600s and 1700s when the Dutch nation exported many of its people under the auspices of the Dutch East Indies Company. The Dutch history in east Asia at this time and on through the Victorian era shares similarities with British empire building so I recognised a lot of the scenarios although I did at times struggle to remember who was who of Bachman-Neeb's ancestors because we jump from one to another and their careers often follow the same trajectories!
Once we meet Bachman-Neeb's immediate family in the 1930s, the pace slows so I could begin to get a better idea of individual people. Unfortunately the focus is on the white Dutch so we don't learn the fate (or even the names) of the family's native Indonesian servants, but we do get clearly described insights into how European women and their children fared during the Japanese wartime occupation. I liked how Perils And Pearls filled out another aspect of Second World War Asia for me alongside novels such as How We Disappeared by Jing-Jing Lee and The Narrow Road To The Deep North by Richard Flanagan, and nonfiction works such as The Rape Of Nanking by Iris Chang.
Perils And Pearls felt as though it had three distinct sections, each written in a different style, which was a little disconcerting. Bachman-Neeb herself was too young to have first-hand recollections of much of what happened in the camps so this memoir recounts her mother's memories, as well as an account of her father's escape to Australia on a leaking old boat. The initial history was rather dry and the boat journey to Australia is in a factual, masculine voice, gleaned from the father's diaries written more-or-less at the time so, for me, it wasn't until Bachman-Neeb's own memories began to coalesce with those of her mother that the memoir really developed a sense of personal depth. I can't begin to imagine how people survived these circumstances (while, of course, many didn't) or how they managed to overcome the resulting trauma in the decades that followed.