Stephanie Jane recenzis Cinder Bella de Kathleen Shoop
A Cinderella retelling
4 steloj
Cinder Bella is, as its title suggests, a retelling of the Cinderella fairytale, but in this novel the tale has been transposed to 1890s Pittsburgh and I felt the combination of a historical fiction narrative with elements of the traditional tale worked really well. I loved how nods to other seasonal traditions are incorporated, such as Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol, but there is also a serious side with poignant depictions of the realities of starving families in the wake of the 1893 financial Panic which created mass unemployment and homelessness. Indeed, the unfortunate banker, Bartholomew Baines, was left destitute as a result of this financial disaster.
As in her previous 'Tis The Season story, The Tin Whistle, Shoop creates a plausible, yet heartwarming cast of characters. At the heart of Cinder Bella, young Bella Darling is a quiet recluse, happier in solitude than in the midst of a crowd, …
Cinder Bella is, as its title suggests, a retelling of the Cinderella fairytale, but in this novel the tale has been transposed to 1890s Pittsburgh and I felt the combination of a historical fiction narrative with elements of the traditional tale worked really well. I loved how nods to other seasonal traditions are incorporated, such as Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol, but there is also a serious side with poignant depictions of the realities of starving families in the wake of the 1893 financial Panic which created mass unemployment and homelessness. Indeed, the unfortunate banker, Bartholomew Baines, was left destitute as a result of this financial disaster.
As in her previous 'Tis The Season story, The Tin Whistle, Shoop creates a plausible, yet heartwarming cast of characters. At the heart of Cinder Bella, young Bella Darling is a quiet recluse, happier in solitude than in the midst of a crowd, but with a heart of gold and the ability to always look on the bright side. She doesn't have much except for a cat, a few hens and plenty borrowed books. I really liked Bella, although I was disappointed with the hens being portrayed as egg-laying machines. Their seemingly magical eggs are central to the storyline and I could understand those eggs needing to be special, however modern commercial hens are engineered to lay just one egg every single day and the toll on their bodies is immense. I cringed whenever Bella's 'spent' hens were laying even more.
That niggle aside, Cinder Bella is a lovely read which gets much of its cheering atmosphere from the interactions between its disparate characters. I loved how each of the boarding house residents had their own unique talents and foibles. Seeing how they made their skills mesh to create a beautiful Christmas in their borrowed home really captured my imagination. Bartholomew's recognition of the importance of making things by hand chimed with my own philosophy. Cinder Bella is, of course, very much a Christmas story so that aspect of it did feel a little strange for me, reading the book as I did in late August. However I did come away feeling a cosy Christmassy glow so if Kathleen Shoop can work her seasonal magic on me in the summertime, I can only imagine what a joy Cinder Bella would be to read in November or December.